Dev.to WebDev 🛠 Dev 👁 0 📖 2 min read

What 255 award-worthy websites taught me about Lighthouse

I run Toprova, a small web design award based in Geneva. Every site we review gets a human jury score (design, usability, creativity, content), and on top of that we run Lighthouse three times on the homepage and keep th

I run Toprova, a small web design award based in Geneva. Every site we review gets a human jury score (design, usability, creativity, content), and on top of that we run Lighthouse three times on the homepage and keep the median.

After 255 measured sites, I had enough data to stop guessing. Here's what came out.

The headline numbers

  • Median performance: 71/100. Only 17% of sites reach 90 or more, and 5% are under 50.
  • Median accessibility: 91/100. 58% reach 90+. Honestly better than I expected.
  • Median best practices: 96/100.
  • Only 9% score 90+ on performance, accessibility and best practices at the same time.

So the beautiful sites are mostly accessible and mostly well built. They're just not fast.

By category

Category Median performance Median accessibility
Portfolio 83 92
3D / WebGL 79 91
Agency 76 92
Brand 73 94
Culture 69 90
Event 68 90
Editorial 67 91
E-commerce 62 93

The surprise for me: 3D / WebGL sites are faster than e-commerce and editorial sites. My guess: heavy-looking sites are often built by people who obsess over every frame, while shops and magazines carry years of tags, widgets and third-party scripts. I haven't measured that part yet.

By stack

Median performance by detected technology (at least 8 sites each):

Technology Sites Median performance
Astro 12 81
WebGL 13 78
Lenis 17 76
GSAP 20 72
WordPress 44 71
Nuxt 16 71
Three.js 20 70
Next.js 55 65
Shopify 13 62

Before anyone sharpens a pitchfork: Toprova itself is built with Next.js. I don't think this table says "framework X is slow". My guess is it says more about what people build with each tool: big product and marketing sites with a lot of client-side JavaScript on one side, content-first sites on the other. Correlation, not a benchmark.

Caveats

  • Desktop Lighthouse profile, homepage only.
  • The sample is ambitious, design-heavy sites chosen by us or submitted by their authors. It's not the web at large.
  • Lighthouse is a lab test, not real user data.

The full, live table is here: Toprova web barometer. It updates every time the ranking does.

One more thing: can AI build a faster site than you?

Everyone has an opinion on vibe coding. We'd rather see the builds. We just opened Build Fight: two creators get the same brief and a time limit (2 hours to 7 days), then the community votes blind. Use Cursor, Claude, v0, or no AI at all. Voters only see the result.

If you want to be in the first vibe coder vs hand coder fight, join the queue.

Disclosure: I built Toprova. I'd love to hear what you would measure instead of (or on top of) Lighthouse.

📰 Read the original article on Dev.to WebDev

Originally published by Dev.to WebDev. Aggregated on AIWithGhost for educational purposes — full credit and traffic to the original publisher.