Dev.to AI 🤖 Ai 👁 0 📖 5 min read

One Marketer Cut Google Search Ads 75%. Where the Money Went

Why are small advertisers cutting Google search ads? Because AI-written answers now take up more of Google's results pages, and some small advertisers say their search clicks stopped paying for themselves. A North Caro

Why are small advertisers cutting Google search ads?

Because AI-written answers now take up more of Google's results pages, and some small advertisers say their search clicks stopped paying for themselves. A North Carolina marketer told The New York Times he cut one client's Google search budget from $2,000 a month to $500.

Quartz summarized the Times story on November 19. Marshall Evans buys Google search ads for small businesses. He told the paper he has been moving money away from Google for six months. For a trophy seller, monthly search spend fell from about $2,000 a year ago, roughly when Google launched AI Mode, to $500 now. The difference went to Tubi, Bing, Reddit and Nextdoor.

One trophy shop doesn't move Google's numbers. Business Model Analyst made that point in its write-up the next day, and it also argued that a small advertiser with a tight budget is exactly who you'd expect to leave first if Google is producing fewer clicks per search.

What do Google's own numbers show?

Google's search ad revenue grew 12% last quarter, short of the roughly 15% Wall Street expected, and search fell below half of Alphabet's quarterly revenue for the first time. Paid clicks grew more slowly than before while the price of each click went up.

Metric (Q3 2026) Figure Source
Search ad revenue growth 12% (about 15% expected) The Times, via Quartz
Search share of Alphabet revenue Under 50% for the first time (49.7%) Quartz, Business Model Analyst
Paid click growth 8%, down from 13% Alphabet 10-Q, per Business Model Analyst
Cost per click Up 4%, after 3% before Alphabet 10-Q, per Business Model Analyst

Google's side of it: the company said search queries grew at their fastest rate in five years, and that it builds the user experience first and scales the ads after. Both things can be true at once. People search more, and fewer of those searches end with someone clicking an ad, because the AI answer settled the question first.

Where is the ad money going instead?

Marshall Evans, the small business ad buyer in the Times story, named four places: Tubi (streaming TV), Bing, Reddit and Nextdoor. Bing got more interesting on November 19, when Microsoft confirmed ads now show next to AI Overviews on Bing in every market except China, running through campaigns advertisers already have.

Microsoft announced it in its November product roundup. There's no separate campaign to build. Performance Max and AI Max campaigns become eligible for the placement, as Relevant Audience and Search Engine Roundtable both reported. Microsoft didn't publish a single performance number for these ads, and the post doesn't describe a way to opt out or a report that breaks the placement out. If you run Performance Max on Microsoft, assume you're already in it and watch your search terms.

Moving money to a cheaper channel only helps if that channel brings customers, not just cheaper clicks. Nextdoor and Reddit can work for local services. Streaming TV builds awareness but rarely gets the phone ringing this week.

What should a business owner running Google Ads do now?

Don't cut on a headline. Pull your cost per booked appointment and cost per paying customer from Google for the last 90 days, compare them with what any other channel costs you, and if Google still brings customers at a profit, keep it and fix what happens after the click.

  1. Track every Google lead to a booked job or a sale in your CRM. Clicks and form fills don't tell you whether the ads are working.
  2. Check where your ads actually show. Search for your top five money keywords on your phone and see whether an AI answer sits above you.
  3. Move 10% to 20% of the budget to a test channel for 60 days, with its own tracking number or form, before you move more.
  4. Answer every paid lead fast. If each click costs more, a missed call or a form nobody touches for a day costs more too. Our piece on why leads go cold has the numbers.
  5. If you run Microsoft Performance Max or AI Max, check the search terms and placements each week now that AI Overviews are part of the mix.

To check whether a channel earns its keep, plug your spend and revenue into our free ROAS calculator. Do it for Google first, then for whatever you're testing, and compare.

We've been running ads for businesses since 2013, and the clients who survive a rising-cost year are the ones who know what a customer costs them. KenjiAI puts every lead from every channel into one CRM with the source attached, and our AI agents text or call new leads within seconds and book them on your calendar. If clicks keep getting pricier, you'll at least get the most out of the ones you pay for.

Is this the end of Google search ads for small businesses?

No. Google still brought in more than $63 billion from search and related products last quarter, and people with a burst pipe or a cracked tooth still search and call, but fewer of those searches turn into ad clicks, so the businesses that do well will be the ones that turn each click into a booked job.

Watch two things over the next quarter: whether Google gives advertisers any reporting on AI Overview and AI Mode placements, and whether Microsoft publishes results for its new AI Overview ads. Until either happens, your own cost per customer is the only number worth trusting.

FAQ

What is Google AI Mode doing to search ads?

AI Mode answers a search with a written response, which leaves fewer chances for someone to click an ad. Google said on its October 28, 2026 earnings call that growth in AI Mode queries was one reason search ad revenue grew more slowly, because AI Mode earns less per query than traditional search.

Are ads now showing in Bing AI Overviews?

Yes. Microsoft Advertising confirmed on November 19, 2026 that ads can appear next to AI Overviews on Bing in all markets except China. The ads run through existing campaigns such as Performance Max and AI Max, with no separate setup, and Microsoft has not published performance data for the placement.

Should a small business stop running Google Ads?

Not because of the headlines. Look at your own cost per booked appointment and cost per paying customer from Google over the last 90 days. If Google still brings customers at a profit, keep it, answer every lead fast, and test other channels with a small share of the budget before moving more.

Did Google search ad revenue fall?

No, it grew 12% in the third quarter of 2026, but that was below the roughly 15% analysts expected, and search dropped below half of Alphabet's quarterly revenue for the first time. Paid clicks grew 8%, down from 13% the quarter before, while cost per click rose 4%.

Originally published at kenjiai.com. Published by the Media Traffics | KenjiAI team.

📰 Read the original article on Dev.to AI

Originally published by Dev.to AI. Aggregated on AIWithGhost for educational purposes — full credit and traffic to the original publisher.