How to Evaluate an LLM Router for Production
Start with the traffic you have Pick a baseline model and measure cost and quality on requests that represent production. Include ordinary cases, failures, and at least one task type you did not use to tune the router.
Start with the traffic you have
Pick a baseline model and measure cost and quality on requests that represent production. Include ordinary cases, failures, and at least one task type you did not use to tune the router. Build a small set of examples with outcomes your team can evaluate consistently. OpenAI's evaluation guide describes how to build representative datasets and keep running evaluations after launch.
Log the chosen model, task class, input and output tokens, cached reads and writes, latency, and whether the result passed or was retried. Classify task types before computing averages. A cheap route that works for summarization may fail a tool call, even when the average success rate looks fine.
Compare spend at the same quality
For a first estimate, let f be the fraction of baseline spend associated with the requests you can reroute. Let r be the cost of those rerouted requests divided by what the same requests cost on the baseline. The estimated fraction saved is f × (1 − r) if spend on the remaining requests is unchanged and there is no extra router overhead.
For example, if the baseline costs $100 and you move requests that accounted for $50 of it, rerouting that portion for $20 would save $30 under those assumptions. The real calculation should include escalations, duplicate calls, and retries. Use the measured total cost to compare routes that meet the same quality threshold.
Run the test with a warm cache
Long conversations can be cheap when their prefixes are already cached. Switching routes can change whether a request gets a cache hit. Measure the resulting reads and writes for each candidate instead of assuming a fixed saving from a move to a cheaper model.
Anthropic documents different costs for cache writes and reads and exceptions by model. Use the actual model and time-to-live values in the replay. Claude prompt caching documentation
Roll out by task class
- Define a pass threshold for each class, such as correct tool arguments or a complete answer.
- Compare a baseline, a simple per-class routing table, and the proposed router using the same examples.
- Track per-class acceptance, fallback rate, cost, and latency. Keep the route and reason visible in logs so an engineer can investigate a regression.
- Roll out one class at a time and keep an override to return it to the baseline. Retest when prompts, models, or traffic change.
Review the router's deployment boundary as part of the evaluation. Depending on the design, a router can receive sensitive prompts or hold provider credentials. Inventory its access and document where its logs and secrets are stored before deploying it alongside production traffic.
This article was prepared with AI assistance. The technical references were checked for this edition.
Originally published by Dev.to AI. Aggregated on AIWithGhost for educational purposes — full credit and traffic to the original publisher.