Dev.to Security πŸ” Cybersecurity πŸ‘ 0 πŸ“– 5 min read

Free apps, ads and in-app purchases under the CRA: is it a commercial activity?

Giving your app away for free does not by itself take it out of the CRA. What matters is whether you make it available in the course of a commercial activity. The CRA covers products made available on the market, and

Giving your app away for free does not by itself take it out of the CRA. What matters is whether you make it available in the course of a commercial activity.

  • The CRA covers products made available on the market, and Article 3(22) says that includes supply "free of charge" when it happens in the course of a commercial activity.
  • Recital 15 names signs of a commercial activity: charging a price, monetising through other services, and requiring personal data as a condition of use. Donations without a profit motive are not one.
  • If your company publishes an app and earns money around it, plan as if it is in scope. Check the scope with the free CRA scope checker.

The test is "commercial activity", not "price"

The Regulation applies to economic operators in relation to products with digital elements that are made available on the market. Under Article 3(22), making available means supplying a product for distribution or use on the Union market in the course of a commercial activity, "whether in return for payment or free of charge". Article 3(21) defines placing on the market as the first making available of a product on the Union market.

The manufacturer definition in Article 3(13) points the same way: you are the manufacturer if you market the product under your name or trademark, "whether for payment, monetisation or free of charge". So a zero price in the store does not decide your role. The commercial-activity test decides whether the Regulation applies at all.

What recital 15 treats as a commercial activity

Recital 15 explains that supply in the course of a commercial activity can be shown in several ways. Read it as a list of signals, not as an exhaustive code:

Signal in recital 15 What it means for an app publisher
Charging a price for the product A paid app, or a paid upgrade of the same app, is clearly commercial.
Charging for technical support beyond cost recovery Selling support or maintenance plans around the app can make the supply commercial.
Monetising through other services The app is free, but you earn money from services connected to it.
Requiring personal data as a condition of use, for reasons other than security, compatibility or interoperability An app that only works if the user hands over personal data you use for other purposes points towards a commercial activity.
Donations without the intention of making a profit Not a commercial activity. Recital 15: accepting donations without the intention of making a profit "should not be considered to be a commercial activity".

Recital 15 is the legal text. The wording in the table is our summary of it; read the recital itself before you rely on a fine point.

Ads, in-app purchases and subscriptions

None of the sources we read for this guide names advertising or in-app purchases. We therefore give our reading, not a rule from the text. An app that sells in-app purchases or subscriptions is charging a price for something connected to the product, and an app funded by advertising earns money through its distribution. Both sit close to the "monetising through other services" signal in recital 15. If your company publishes the app and earns money from it, the safe working assumption is that the CRA applies.

The Commission guidance of 27 July 2026 is non-binding. According to the Orrick summary, it treats standalone software as placed on the market when it is supplied for the first time for distribution or use "in a commercial context", and a later download of the same version as making that product available, not a new placement. Software executed remotely for user access "regularly falls outside the scope", which matters for a pure web service but not for an app that users install.

Free apps from a company versus hobby projects

Recital 18 deals with free and open-source software and says that software not monetised by its manufacturer should not be considered a commercial activity. It also says financial support from manufacturers does not in itself make the activity commercial. That recital is about free and open-source software. A company that ships a closed-source app under its own brand, free, but funds it through ads or purchases is not helped by it. The Orrick summary adds that a natural person offering a free version is outside the CRA, whereas a legal person offering both free and paid versions has obligations for the free version too.

Note that the two law-firm summaries we read word the personal-data signal slightly differently. The Commission guidance itself (the annex to C(2026) 5252) was not accessible to us in this run, so check its wording on this point before you build an argument on it.

What to do

Your app Working assumption
Paid app, subscription or in-app purchases In scope. You are the manufacturer if it is published under your name (Article 3(13)).
Free app that promotes or supports your paid product or service Likely in scope (monetisation through other services, recital 15).
Free app funded by ads Plan as in scope; this is our reading, not a rule named in the text.
Free app, no revenue, no personal data beyond security and operation, donations only May fall outside. Write down why, per app.

Whatever you conclude, keep a short written note per app: who publishes it, how it is funded, what data it requires, and the recital or article your conclusion rests on. If you decide an app is in scope, the next steps are in the 12-step readiness checklist. For the basic scope question see Does the CRA apply to mobile apps?, and for who counts as manufacturer when an agency built the app see Agency or client.

Try it on your own app: the free Shipmark scanner builds a CycloneDX SBOM from a lockfile in the browser and checks it against OSV.dev. Not sure the CRA applies? Use the six-question CRA check.

Sources

This guide summarises EU law and non-binding Commission guidance for practical use. It is not legal advice. Related: Does the CRA apply to mobile apps? Β· Readiness checklist Β· Who is the manufacturer? Β· Companion apps.

Originally published on shipmark.eu, where the guide is kept up to date. More guides for app teams: shipmark.eu/guides.

πŸ“° Read the original article on Dev.to Security

Originally published by Dev.to Security. Aggregated on AIWithGhost for educational purposes β€” full credit and traffic to the original publisher.