Customer Passwords Don't Survive a Move to Shopify. Does It Still Matter?
If you've moved a store to Shopify, you've probably had this conversation with the client: "So every customer has to make a new account?" Shopify's own migration checklist is clear about why. It says to "encourage yo
If you've moved a store to Shopify, you've probably had this conversation with the client:
"So every customer has to make a new account?"
Shopify's own migration checklist is clear about why. It says to "encourage your customers to sign up again if your store uses customer accounts. Because passwords are encrypted, only customer records are imported to Shopify."
That makes sense. A properly stored password is a hash, and you can't move a hash between two systems that check passwords differently. So names, emails and addresses come across, and the passwords don't.
The twist: Shopify's newer accounts don't need a password
While reading up on this, I found that Shopify's newer customer accounts can work without passwords at all. From Shopify's Help Center:
"They enter their email address and receive a one-time 6-digit verification code. A password isn't required to sign in."
So on a store using the new customer accounts, the "lost password" problem mostly disappears. A returning customer types their email, gets a code and is in. Their imported record, address and (if you moved them) order history are already there.
That changes the launch email. Instead of "please create a new password", it's more like "we've moved, sign in with your email and we'll send you a code."
What I'm still not sure about
Passwords were the obvious problem. The quieter ones are the data that has to be checked one item at a time:
- Gift card balances and store credit. Do the codes still work, and do the balances match?
- Subscriptions. Saved payment methods live with the payment provider or subscription app, not in a CSV.
-
Old URLs. Shopify won't let you redirect its fixed paths like
/productsand/collections, so the redirect map has to be done before the domain switches, not after.
I've been working these into a launch checklist with go/no-go gates (data counts match, redirects tested, test orders pass for every payment method, and so on). If it's useful, the checklist and a free Excel worksheet are here.
Over to you
For people who've done a few Shopify migrations:
- Do you still send a "set a new password" email, or have you moved clients to the code-based sign-in?
- Did customers get confused by the 6-digit code the first time? Any support tickets about it?
- What broke that you didn't expect? Gift cards, subscriptions, reviews, something else?
- How long did you keep the old store running after the switch?
Real stories welcome, good or bad. Migrations are one of those jobs where everyone learns something the hard way.
Originally published by Dev.to WebDev. Aggregated on AIWithGhost for educational purposes — full credit and traffic to the original publisher.