Dev.to AI 🤖 Ai 👁 0 📖 1 min read

Ask an AI Which Brand to Buy. Ask Again Tomorrow. Good Luck.

A pilot study by AI visibility firm Supercite found that the brands recommended by ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode change dramatically from one day to the next. The same 210 buying questions were

Ask an AI Which Brand to Buy. Ask Again Tomorrow. Good Luck.

AI brand picks flip overnight

A pilot study by AI visibility firm Supercite found that the brands recommended by ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode change dramatically from one day to the next. The same 210 buying questions were put to all four systems on consecutive days, and 84 percent of answers named a different set of brands on day two. In 27 percent of cases, a brand that appeared on day one vanished completely.

Gemini was the most volatile, with roughly 95 percent of answers changing their brand lineup day to day. Google AI Overviews was the most stable, but even there 67 percent of answers changed. Cited source pages rotated even faster than the brand names: only 42 percent of cited pages overlapped between days, versus 61 percent of brands. These systems are assembling answers on the fly from a noisy mix of live web pages, so the recommendation is less a verdict than a snapshot of a moving target.

Key points

  • 84 percent of answers named a different brand set on the second day
  • 27 percent of day-one brands disappeared entirely
  • Gemini changed 95 percent of the time; AI Overviews 67 percent
  • Cited pages overlapped only 42 percent between days
  • Sample: 210 buying questions across four AI surfaces on consecutive days

There is comedy in a machine that cannot keep its own story straight for 24 hours, but the implication is serious: if AI shopping lists are this unstable, neither shopper trust nor brand spending rests on solid ground.

Read the full story on threerouter: https://www.threerouter.com/blog/484

📰 Read the original article on Dev.to AI

Originally published by Dev.to AI. Aggregated on AIWithGhost for educational purposes — full credit and traffic to the original publisher.