Dev.to Security 🔐 Cybersecurity 👁 0 📖 3 min read

A Black Friday VPN price is three numbers. The banner shows the wrong one

Every VPN Black Friday banner leads with a percentage and a monthly price. Neither is the number that leaves your account. I maintain a small site about self-hosting WireGuard, and this week I read the order pages of thr

Every VPN Black Friday banner leads with a percentage and a monthly price. Neither is the number that leaves your account. I maintain a small site about self-hosting WireGuard, and this week I read the order pages of three commercial VPNs to put them next to the cost of a VPS over the same period. Here is the arithmetic, with the date of each reading, because these prices move during the sale.

The three numbers on an order page

  1. The monthly figure in the banner. It is a division, nothing is billed monthly on these plans.
  2. The amount billed today. It covers a first term of 12, 24 or 27 months depending on the provider.
  3. The renewal. What the plan costs once the first term ends. Not every provider prints it next to the price.

What I read

Plan Banner price Billed for the first term Renewal printed Read on
Proton VPN Plus, 2 years $2.49 / month $59.76 for 24 months $83.88 every 12 months 16 Nov 2026
Proton Unlimited, 1 year $6.49 / month $77.88 for 12 months $119.88 every 12 months 16 Nov 2026
Surfshark Starter, 24 + 3 months €2.49 / month €67.23 for 27 months not in the plan card 16 Nov 2026
Surfshark One, 24 + 3 months €2.49 / month €67.23 for 27 months not in the plan card 16 Nov 2026
NordVPN Basic, 2 years €2.99 / month €80.73 for 27 months not read 14 Nov 2026

Currencies differ because each provider showed its own. I did not convert them, a conversion would add a number nobody printed.

The math the banner skips

plans = {
    # name: (billed_first_term, months_first_term, renewal_per_year or None)
    "Proton VPN Plus": (59.76, 24, 83.88),
    "Surfshark Starter": (67.23, 27, None),
    "NordVPN Basic": (80.73, 27, None),
}

for name, (first, months, renewal) in plans.items():
    line = f"{name}: {first / months:.2f} per month over the first {months} months"
    if renewal:
        three_years = first + renewal          # 24 months + 12 months
        line += f", {three_years:.2f} over 36 months ({three_years / 36:.2f} per month)"
    print(line)
Proton VPN Plus: 2.49 per month over the first 24 months, 143.64 over 36 months (3.99 per month)
Surfshark Starter: 2.49 per month over the first 27 months
NordVPN Basic: 2.99 per month over the first 27 months

Two things come out of it:

  • Proton's third year costs more than its first two together. $83.88 against $59.76. That is not a trap, it is printed under the price, but the effective monthly cost goes from $2.49 to $3.99 the moment you keep the plan for a third year.
  • For the two others I cannot compute a third year at all, because the plan card did not show a renewal when I read it. A missing renewal line is not a zero. Until you find it at checkout, assume the standard yearly price.

A smaller oddity: Surfshark One was billed exactly the same as Surfshark Starter on 16 November. If the cheaper tier was your plan, the tier above cost nothing more that day.

And the self-hosted option?

I expected the VPS to win on price. It does not. A Contabo Cloud VPS 4 was 5.50 € a month on a 24-month term when I read it on 22 October 2026, about 132 € over two years, roughly twice the first-term totals above.

What the server buys is something else: an IP address nobody shares with you (fewer CAPTCHAs, but also tied to you), logs you configure yourself, and exactly one location instead of dozens. If that is what you are after, it is an evening of WireGuard setup. If you want many countries for the lowest bill, the subscription is the rational purchase and there is no point pretending otherwise.

Four checks before paying

  1. Read the line under the price. "Billed X for the first N months" is the real number.
  2. Look for the renewal line. If it is absent, go to checkout before deciding.
  3. Divide by months before comparing: 24, 27 and 12 month terms are not comparable as totals.
  4. Use the refund window to test the client on your own network during the first week.

I keep the full table, with each price re-read during the sale and dated, on this page: Black Friday VPN deals 2026, prices read on the providers' pages and the 2-year math. Disclosure: that page contains affiliate links, this post does not.

If you have read a renewal price for Surfshark or NordVPN at checkout this week, post it in the comments with the date and country, I will add it to the comparison.

📰 Read the original article on Dev.to Security

Originally published by Dev.to Security. Aggregated on AIWithGhost for educational purposes — full credit and traffic to the original publisher.